Prompt Engineering · Posted by David O'Brien ·

Why I Stopped Using AI to Write My Newsletter

7

used ai for 6 months for my newsletter. engagement dropped 30%. went back to writing myself. heres why

the main thing ive noticed is role prompting works way better than people give it credit for

6 replies

6 Replies

9

role prompting is underrated but i think the bigger issue is ai flattens your voice. newsletters live or die on personality and gpt just... sands everything smooth

9

PSA: some AI tools share your conversations for training. opt out if you care about privacy. i had this happen to me last month and it was a pain to debug. save yourselves the trouble

4

lmao yes this. substack specifically has vague wording in their terms about third party integrations. read it before you paste anything sensitive

0

anyone know if how long did it take you to get good results with this approach?

2

interesting. 30% drop is significant but was your cadence the same? sometimes switching workflow changes publish frequency and that alone tanks open rates

1

what worked for me was using ai only for the outline and transition sentences, then writing every actual point myself. keeps structure tight without losing the voice